林皓, 陈振宇. 实质问的本质与演化——手语“摊手”等语言现象的启发[J]. 外国语, 2020, 43(4): 75-91.
引用本文: 林皓, 陈振宇. 实质问的本质与演化——手语“摊手”等语言现象的启发[J]. 外国语, 2020, 43(4): 75-91.
LIN Hao, CHEN Zhenyu. The Origin and Grammaticalization of Content Question[J]. Journal of Foreign Languages, 2020, 43(4): 75-91.
Citation: LIN Hao, CHEN Zhenyu. The Origin and Grammaticalization of Content Question[J].Journal of Foreign Languages, 2020, 43(4): 75-91.

实质问的本质与演化——手语“摊手”等语言现象的启发

The Origin and Grammaticalization of Content Question

  • 摘要:实质句的形成与演化,必须结合有声语(包括方言)和手语等不同模态的语言材料来进行探讨。首先,我们集中讨论一类无疑问词的实质问,即缺省问和话题问。然后详细描述手语中"摊手"这一手势词的多种功能,发现它可能是语言中疑问词的"雏形";与缺省问一样,摊手也是真正的"原始"操作,并未高度语法化,而是更为语用性的、本源性的语言现象。不过二者在形式上有差异,"摊手"有语音形式,虽然受限于句末位置,但能独用,甚至表达语气,即兼顾了实质问的"成分残缺"与"话轮让渡"两个方面。我们由此提出"语气词+疑问词"双轮驱动假说。我们认为,最原始实质问形式为缺省-摊手,从这里开始分两个方向发展:语气词,如成都话的"咹",发展为话题问标记,还能与其他问题形式共现,并充当疑问强化词;万能疑问词,如古汉语中的"何",手语的"晃食指"。由万能疑问词再进一步分化出多个具体WH疑问词,则是大多数语言的常态;而有独立的、较完善的实质疑问语气成分的语言,如汉语(及相关方言)、俄语则属于少数现象。

    Abstract:What is the essence of content question and its evolution? This article attempts to deal with the issue by looking at the data from both spoken languages (including dialects) and sign languages. First, we focus on the discussion of a kind of content question:questions without WH words, which is composed of two types:elliptical question and topic question. Second, the multi-functions of PALM-UP in sign languages are described and analyzed, which turned out to be a preliminary form of grammatical operation. Elliptical question and PALM UP share some features like less grammaticalized, but differ in some ways:PALM UP has form and independent usage, which signifies both ‘emptiness of a constituent’ and ‘turn-giving’, two essential semantic roles demanded by content question. Therefore, we propose the hypothesis of Double Wheel Drive, i.e. the earliest form of content question is elliptical-PALM UP, which further develops into two directions:the question particles and general WH words. Most of the languages have developed a rich system of WH words, however, only a few have a complete system of WH particles, which are represented by Chinese, Russian etc.

/

    返回文章
    返回